What is Citynoise?..... Authors..... Cities.....  

browse by city

Brooklyn, NY (1200)
New York, NY (1035)
Toronto, ON (946)
Montreal, QC (435)
London, UK (316)
Houston, TX (297)
Oakland, CA (253)
Philadelphia, PA (208)
Seattle, WA (191)
Queens, NY (188)
Minneapolis, MN (110)
San Francisco, CA (105)
Sao Paulo, Brasil (102)
Seoul, South Korea (100)
Newark, NJ (95)
Chicago, IL (94)
Mpumalanga, South Africa (91)
Melbourne, AU (79)
Schenectady, NY (78)
Cleveland, OH (75)
complete city list

browse by author

Peter (1348)
joey (455)
jack (323)
EvilGentleman (298)
hool (247)
Franny Wentzel (244)
groovehouse (207)
CartLegger (179)
Jamie (171)
CE (170)
Michelle (160)
fuzzytank (155)
elaine (151)
Elicar (151)
Biff (146)
serlingrod (135)
Catherine Penfold-Waxman (131)
GGP (130)
chiamattt (127)
Tyfoid Kid (125)
complete author list

best of

2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

from the archives

Central Park & Skyline

CPW from CPE Baseball Fields Northern NYC Skyline

Central Park & Skyline

Beach's Pneumatic Subway

- Franny Wentzel - Wednesday, April 8th, 2009 : goo

[previous] :: [next]

Mention of the Vacuum Train article brings to mind Alfred Ely Beach's demonstration pneumatic railway of the 1870s.

image 32228

image 32229

Constructed in secrecy over 58 days across from City Hall Park, this futuristic system used compressed air blowers to whisk passengers the grand total of one block's distance between Warren and Murray streets.

image 32230

Beach used a shield system to dig out his tunnel that he originally claimed was a a pneumatic tube package delivery system to get around Tammany Hall.

image 32231

Contemporary photo of the tunnel.

image 32232

Sketches of the completed demonstration system.

image 32233

image 32234

Passengers trying the new system. Any money collected was given to charity as the company had no franchise yet.

image 32235

image 32236

The system never got beyond the prototype stage and was shut down after a few years. New York suffered for decades with a smelly sooty elevated railroad system before subway took root in the next century.

In 1912 the building above the terminal burned down and parts of the tunnel were unearthed.

image 32237

image 32238

image 32239

Modern construction has removed virtually all traces of the system - but I'm sure one of you Citynoiser would like to prove me wrong ;0)

This article was viewed 39672 times (Counting ceased in 2017)

Internet Archive:*/

adam: 8th Apr 2009 - 12:41 GMT

Great article!

CartLegger: 8th Apr 2009 - 13:49 GMT

Yep. It really belongs here. Wish we could find it!

The real issue of Beach's subway is not the nature invention, but the stubborn determination on the part of Tammany Hall not to allow a subway to compete with the elevated track's monopoly.

Reminds me a bit of today's stubborness as concerns bridge tolls.

Franny Wentzel: 8th Apr 2009 - 13:57 GMT

Once The State has an open pathway to your pocketbook it's hard as hell to close it again.

JoeyD: 8th Apr 2009 - 14:08 GMT

I think it is amazing how important that pneumatics have remained and how conceptually ahead of its time a system like this could have been

Peter: 8th Apr 2009 - 14:13 GMT

totally... it was like the victorian version of .

nice post franny- thanks for coming through with this one! its got me itching to find out if any remnants of it are still around, despite the fact that all sources so far point to no, heh.

Franny Wentzel: 8th Apr 2009 - 14:27 GMT

Here's a picture of the building fire that exposed the tunnel entrance...

image 32240

Amazing that they were able to save the middle tower with that kind of damage.

Joe Brennan: 8th Apr 2009 - 19:08 GMT

Franny: Would it hurt to credit the source of all these images? Besides finding the originals in many different publications and laying them on a scanner I had to do digital cleanup to make them look this good. Way more than anyone wants to know is at

CartLegger: Actually state Senator Tweed introduced the first bill in favor of Beach in 1870. It was in the newspapers. Probably Tweed was going to supply the laborers from constituents in his district, and possibly get some stock, but I am guessing on his motives. By 1872 Beach was telling a new story about Tweed opposing him, which many people since then have repeated, so that he would get support from the reform people.

Sean Hopkins: 8th Apr 2009 - 20:39 GMT

These pictures are on the wall in the Subway (sandwich place) near me. I am enlightened.

Franny Wentzel: 8th Apr 2009 - 21:48 GMT

A thousand apologies. I'd linked to the Wiki article so people would have links to all the sources I'd gone through. Yours was the first of theirs. Wish there was a cleaner way to do hyperlinks on this blog.

A reprint of an 1870s article.

Anais NIN: 9th Apr 2009 - 06:09 GMT

Public-domain photos are public-domain.

tyrant: 9th Apr 2009 - 18:33 GMT

very nice article

i don't have a name: 6th Oct 2009 - 21:46 GMT

I agree with CartLegger.
They should open and extend the pneumatic tube as a museum piece or something.

97: 10th Aug 2010 - 18:09 GMT

america should use a pneumaric railway as transport

Franny Wentzel: 24th May 2016 - 23:17 GMT

image 52899

From today's Married to the Sea comic...

[previous] :: [next]

from the archives

Room with a View

When I got to Salamanca I couldn't believe how lucky I was to be staying where I was. If you ever find yourself there, I can recommend a room with a view: Make sure you ask for...

Room with a View

from the archives

Gun Farm

Shane and I went to Cambodia a couple of years ago and shot a lot of guns. Oh it was so much fun. Anyway, we had our picture taken with the workers of the gun farm. I'm the one with...

Gun Farm

from the archives

Moody Montreal

Moody Montreal